That Is Just Wrong!

I’m pretty sure that this is not a national movement but I was surprised to read in the Tacoma News-Tribune this morning that a sports writer is advocating a play-clock in baseball!  Is he crazy? That is just wrong! The joy of baseball is its unhurried pace. The contest matches the skill of the pitcher against the skill of the batter. It pits the throwing ability of the fielders against the quickness and agility of the runners. We watch and wait (emphasis on ‘wait’) to see if the pitcher will be able to strike out the batter or if the batter will jump on a bad pitch and get a hit. Then we wait to see what that runner will do once on base. Its an intricate game with numerous battles taking place on the field over a span of nine innings – not a fixed time period.

According to the article, umpires would assess a walk against any pitcher that took more than 20 seconds between pitches! Why not just call a strike on every foul ball (not just the first two) to prevent a batter from fouling off an unlimited number of pitches? While you’re at it you could assess a ball on a throw to first base that does not get the runner out. Perhaps the best idea is to limit the total number of pitches that may be thrown against any one batter to to 6.  If you can’t get the batter out in 6 pitches then he is awarded first base. That would certainly move the game along and would likely result in more runs (most of them by walks). Now wouldn’t that be exciting! If high scores are your goal than prohibit the insertion of a relief pitcher during innings! Make him pitch an entire inning unless injured. And if he claims an injury in order to be removed he must go on the 10-day disabled list!

Don’t you just love messing with all the rules?

I say, leave the clock to sports that were created with a time limit as part of the contest and leave baseball to set its own pace!

What do you think!

2 thoughts on “That Is Just Wrong!

  1. secondchair Post author

    Interesting that your arguments for speeding up the game rely on the game-delaying tactics of one team – the Red Sox. They continue to give us plenty of reasons to dislike them. The umpires could put an end to that behavior if they really wanted to.

  2. Scott Ross

    You’re wrong on this one! It is a game that was meant to have a certain pace…a rhythm. That has been thrown out of whack in recent years with the pace of playoff games and particularly Yankee vs. Red Sox games slowing down to one pitch per minute. The games are routinely four hours long and grind to a near standstill.

    I don’t know that the solution is a time clock. I think that is an attempt at fixing the wrong problem. I would advocate one singe rule change: between pitches, a batter is only allowed to step out of the batter’s box with one foot. Get your sign, take a breath and step back in the box. I think the problem isn’t so much the pitcher, but the batter. The manager wont give the signal to his catcher, then catcher to pitcher until batter steps in the box…so everything stands still while Big Poppy slowly walks five steps out, takes two practice swings, re-velcro’s his gloves and spits and adjusts himself between every single pitch.

    There you have it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s