David Kinnaman & Gabe Lyons collaborated on unchristian in 2007 using research from the Barna Group. Through careful review of extensive research, unchristian identifies six perceptions that younger Americans (Busters and Mosaics) hold of today’s evangelicals. The list is no surprise to those of us who live and work inside the evangelical community, and it’s not good:  1) Hypocritical – Christians fake their faith, pretending to be something they are not. 2) Obsessed with converts –  Do Christians care about people or decisions? 3) Antihomosexual – Christians are perceived as hating the sin AND the sinner.  4) Sheltered – rather than face tough issues Christians settle for simplistic solutions.  5) Too political – those outside the Christian faith feel that Christians have traded the spiritual beliefs for a political agenda. 6) Judgmental – Christians do not appear to love anyone, including other Christians.

Those items are really not much of a surprise. If you have had any conversations with younger adults outside the church you are well aware of these perceptions. What is more of a surprise is that these views are also commonly held by young adults inside the church! It appears that there is an increasingly widening generational gap between those who are committed to perpetuating status-quo Christianity (with a few tweaks and nudges here and there) and those who see the church filled with people who behave more unchristian than christian.

Kinnaman and Lyons present a thorough review of the research without advocating a more palatable, non-offensive Gospel. Instead they strongly affirm a clear and complete Gospel where “Jesus is the legitimate path to a dynamic spiritual world that exists beyond our five senses.” The problem may be that today’s younger adults do not see that clear and complete Gospel in their churches. Instead, “even after participating in Christian churches, this is not apparent to most young outsiders who see following Christ something like belong to a social club that adheres to a nice set of life principles.” (p. 124)

Gabe Lyons’ afterword reads like a manifesto for a new day in the church. On p. 224 he writes: “It comes down to this: we must become Christlike again.  …when you recognize that being Christian demands more than simply saying a prayer, assenting to a statement of belief, and going to heaven when you die, it becomes more personally challenging. Add the concept that being Christian means being God’s agent of common grace in the world, and the task becomes even more sobering.” (p. 224-225)

If you are a leader in the church you should read this book.  Secondchair leaders will find significant support for re-shaping ministries within the church and equipping people to create new and effective ministries of compassion, generosity, and service in their communities. Mine the data in unchristian and you will question whether you should really be expending energy to create more Sunday School classes, men’s breakfasts, or evangelism seminars. The world outside the church is changing rapidly and the church has not responded effectively to this changing culture. To keep the church from being completely marginalized, NextGen Christian leaders will need to lead the way. unchristian points them in the right direction.

6 thoughts on “unchristrian

  1. Kirsten Kilcup

    Enjoyed the msg Sunday and came here to further feed my pondering…In our small group, we talked about what we could do to change those perceptions. Individually, I believe taking a relational approach is effective and has been–at least in my experience–missing from the Church at large.

    I’ve been pushing around the sheltering point in my mind…that’s a hard one for me to bring down to community level, largely because I believe people’s perceptions of sheltering/simplistic answers also occurs within the church and often ends up dealing with people’s lifestyle choices rather than theological points. Are my neighbors going to think I’m sheltered/sheltering because I believe Jesus is the only way, or because I don’t have cable? They could assume that I’m sheltering my kids and not dealing with the tough issue of monitoring/teaching them about what’s appropriate. BUT, because I have formed a relationship with quite of few of them (mostly those that also have kids), they know that it’s because I’m cheap and would spend my days watching HGTV if I had cable–my kids still watch cartoons, they just watch them on youtube. My neighbors could, of course, also believe that Jesus as the way is simplistic, but what am I supposed to do about that?? It IS “simplistic” in that it is simple, but it’s TRUE. People outside of ANY religion have perceptions and make judgments about that religion, and it’s hard to combat that without forming a relationship so they can see that I’m not an ignoramus. 🙂

    I definitely think that more people seeing Christians acting as agents of common grace will slowly change perceptions at a community level. This, of course, requires us to “go out” rather than just live in our bubble of God-is-awesome.

    Sorry for the long ramble…gotta love thinking-out-loud blog comments:).

  2. Ryan

    That’s a great idea, Joe!

    Actually, could you just save me a copy for next Sunday?
    That way I could bring my CD player and listen to it during
    next week’s service.

  3. Pingback: Tweets that mention unchristrian « View From the Second Chair -- Topsy.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s